Skip to content
Try Udemy

How We Review Courses

This page explains how CourseJournal reviews online courses, so you can judge how much weight to give our verdicts. If a review does not follow this process, that is a mistake on our part and we want to hear about it.

We take the courses we review

A review begins with enrolling. We work through the lectures, attempt the exercises and projects, and use the instructor support and community where they exist. We do not write reviews from a course landing page, a syllabus, or another publication’s coverage.

Where a course is very long, we say in the review how much of it we completed. We would rather tell you we finished eight of twelve modules than imply a completeness we cannot back up.

What we assess

  • Curriculum. What the course genuinely covers, how deep it goes, and whether the running order helps a newcomer or assumes knowledge it never taught.
  • Instructor. Their background in the subject, how clearly they explain difficult ideas, and whether they are still responding to questions.
  • Exercises and projects. Whether you build anything, whether the work is checked, and whether it resembles the tasks the skill is actually used for.
  • Currency. When the material was last updated, and whether tools, versions, or practices shown in the videos have since moved on.
  • Support and community. Q&A responsiveness, errata, and whether earlier learners’ questions have been addressed.
  • Price and value. The realistic price including typical discounts, weighed against the alternatives, free resources included.
  • Certificate. What the completion certificate is, and candidly, what it is worth to an employer.

How we compare

No course is assessed in isolation. We look at the other courses competing on the same topic, including free ones, and ask which learner each is genuinely the better choice for. A review that cannot name the reader who should skip the course is not finished.

Scores and recommendations

Scores reflect teaching quality, depth, and value for the time a course demands. They are not influenced by commission rates, coupon availability, or a platform’s willingness to work with us. We do not accept payment for a positive review, and we do not give platforms or instructors approval over our conclusions before publication.

Updates

Courses change after we publish. Instructors re-record sections, curricula are restructured, and prices move. When we learn of a material change we revisit the course and update the review, and the review carries the date it was last checked. Older reviews we have not rechecked recently say so rather than implying they are current.

How we are funded

CourseJournal may earn a commission when you enroll through our links, at no extra cost to you. That funds the time it takes to actually take these courses. It has no bearing on which courses we cover or what we conclude. See our fact-checking policy for how we handle accuracy, or contact us to flag something we got wrong.